The Quad’s Space Collaboration: Advancing Satellite and Space Security Initiatives

Abstract

Quadrilateral Security dialogue i.e. QUAD comprises Australia, India, Japan, and the United States. In recent years, these nations have significantly enhanced their collaboration in space-related activities, recognizing the strategic importance of space in ensuring regional security and addressing global challenges. It has become a crucial grouping especially in the Indo-Pacific region. In September 2021, they also established ‘QUAD Space Working Group’ during the first in person QUAD Leaders’ Summit

In the meeting in 2023, The United States called for space cooperation in which QUAD members would share information obtained by satellites for the purpose of earth observation and disaster mitigation. Space cooperation would also allow the Quad members to keep abreast of China’s movements in the Indo-Pacific region. (Reinecke & Dutcher, 2023)

QUAD Developments in Space Collaboration

Emphasis on the development of superior space capabilities has only increased in response to the Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, which highlighted how decisive such capabilities can prove in an international conflict. Satellite technology has been instrumental in guiding Ukraine’s drone strikes on Russian tanks and positions. In February 2022, the Ukrainian military was able to prevent the fall of Kyiv with a precise attack based on imagery data obtained from commercial Starlink satellites.

In May 2022, three months into the war and amid escalating conflict, a Quad Summit was held in Tokyo. According to a senior government official who attended the summit, from the first day of discussions, the United States strongly pushed for the Indo-Pacific Partnership for Maritime Domain Awareness (IPMDA) – which stipulates the sharing and disclosure of satellite imagery data to assess the state of the ocean — be the centerpiece of the joint statement. The move clearly reflected the priority Washington places on deterring China’s maritime activities in the region.

Starting in 2011, the three allies have met annually to convene the Japan-U.S.-Australia Space Security Dialogue. Australia and Japan are also regulars at two of the United States’ major space-related strategic exercises: the Schriever Wargame, held at Maxwell Air Force Base in Alabama, and Global Sentinel, a Space Situational Awareness (SSA) Tabletop Exercise (TTX) organized by U.S. Strategic Command. (Reinecke & Dutcher, 2023)

Bilaterally, the United States and Japan boast particularly close cooperation owing to their unique security relationship. In May 2013, the two concluded a memorandum of understanding (MOU) on SSA system services and information sharing involving Japan’s Quasi-Zenith Satellite System (QZSS), a regional time transfer and satellite-based augmentation system developed by the Japanese government to enhance U.S.-operated GPS in the Asia-Oceania region. Two years later, in April 2015, the Guidelines for Japan-U.S. Defense Cooperation was revised to include an independent section on space and cyberspace cooperation for the first time, and in January 2023, officials from both countries issued official declarations that their bilateral security alliance extends into outer space. (Reinecke & Dutcher, 2023)

The United States and Australia also share a longstanding SSA partnership dating back to the 2010 session of the Australia-United States Ministerial Consultations (AUSMIN). The 2021 AUSMIN also included an affirmation of the importance of space security and discussion plans for a Space Framework Agreement

In contrast, bilateral cooperation between Japan and Australia remains less defense-oriented in nature. The first bilateral space cooperation between the two, a formal agreement on Science and Technology (S&T) cooperation between the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) and the Australian Space Agency (ASA) was concluded in July 2020. (Reinecke & Dutcher, 2023)

Although India had previously preferred to contain its space cooperation to the realms of exploration and S&T, it made headlines in April 2022 upon concluding an MOU on SSA with the United States during the Fourth U.S.-India 2+2 Ministerial Dialogue. The Defense Space Dialogue they had scheduled for later that year has yet to come to fruition, however. India and Japan have similarly begun hosting information exchanges for their respective space agencies focusing on space security, technological cooperation, and rules and norms.

Challenges in QUAD’s Space collaboration

1. Technological Disparities: The Quad nations possess varying levels of technological advancement in their space programs. For instance, while the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) has made significant strides, differences in technological capabilities may affect seamless collaboration.

2. Data Sharing and Standardization:Effective collaboration requires the establishment of common standards for data collection, processing, and sharing. Disparities in data protocols can lead to inefficiencies and misinterpretations, hindering joint initiatives.

3. Cybersecurity Threats:As space assets become increasingly integrated into national infrastructures, they become attractive targets for cyber-attacks. Ensuring the cybersecurity of shared systems is crucial to maintain trust and operational integrity.

4. Legal and Regulatory Frameworks:Each Quad nation operates under its own legal and regulatory frameworks governing space activities. Harmonizing these regulations is essential to facilitate smooth cooperation and prevent legal disputes.

5. Funding and Resource Allocation:Collaborative space projects require substantial investments. Aligning budgetary priorities and securing consistent funding across all member nations can be challenging.

6. Geopolitical Sensitivities:Joint space initiatives may be perceived by other countries as strategic moves, potentially leading to geopolitical tensions. Navigating these sensitivities is crucial to maintain regional stability.

General Risks and Effects of Political Regime Change in QUAD Space Cooperation

1. Shifts in Budget Allocation:Changes in leadership can lead to funding cuts or redirection of resources away from Quad space projects.

2. Changes in Strategic Focus:: Some governments may prioritize military applications, while others might emphasize climate monitoring or commercial space ventures

3. Technology Transfer & Security Concerns:: New administrations may impose stricter export control laws, affecting collaboration on satellite and defense technologies

4. Diplomatic Relations:If political tensions rise between any Quad nations (e.g., due to trade disputes or regional security concerns), space collaboration may suffer as a result

Establishing long term, legally binding agreements can protect quad space initiatives from political shifts. Also strengthening private sector collaboration (e.g., partnerships between ISRO, NASA, JAXA, and Australian companies) in space must increase to ensure continuity. Overall, while regime changes in Quad countries can create uncertainty, strong institutional partnerships and shared strategic interests can help sustain long-term space cooperation.

Future of Quad Space Collaboration

● The Quad countries recognize the importance of space as a strategic domain, particularly in countering challenges from adversaries like China.

● Future collaboration is likely to include satellite surveillance, space situational awareness (SSA), anti-satellite (ASAT) defense measures, and secure communication networks.

● Example: The U.S. Space Force and Australian Space Command are already working on joint military space initiatives, which may extend to Quad-wide cooperation.● The Quad nations could collaborate on launching Earth observation satellites for climate monitoring, disaster management, and defense intelligence.

● Example: India’s ISRO and Japan’s JAXA have experience in remote sensing and weather satellites, which could be integrated with U.S. and Australian satellite networks.

● Japan (JAXA) and the U.S. (NASA) are heavily involved in the Artemis program, which aims to return humans to the Moon. India’s ISRO is also working on its Gaganyaan human spaceflight program.

● The Quad could collaborate on lunar exploration, robotic missions, and Mars exploration, with Australia providing ground station support for deep-space communication.

● Japan’s SLIM lander, NASA’s Artemis missions, and India’s Chandrayaan program all indicate potential areas for synergy.

● The private space industry is growing rapidly, and SpaceX, Blue Origin, Rocket Lab, and India’s private space startups (like Skyroot & Agnikul) could drive collaboration.

● Public-private partnerships (PPPs) will be crucial in enabling cost-effective and efficient space missions.

C

Conclusion

According to an executive at a private satellite company based in Washington, D.C., “The war in Ukraine has made the world realize that satellite imagery data holds the key to future war efforts.” As the nature of warfare is changing, Space has become one of the most prominent warfronts. China is also investing heavily in the space industry and to counter adversaries like China Quad countries need more cooperation in advanced space technologies. From a security point of view, exchange of sensitive and critical information through satellite images, particularly, over the Indo-Pacific region should not be ignored. This space collaboration between Quad countries will be the most crucial thing from a security perspective as well as it will take these countries to the new heights of space development. SpaceX is well-positioned to be a key enabler of Quad space cooperation, providing launch services, satellite communications, and deep-space transport. However, for long-term success, Quad countries must develop independent capabilities while leveraging SpaceX’s advanced technology were beneficial. Public-private partnerships, technology-sharing agreements, and strategic coordination will define the future of Quad’s space collaboration.

References:

Pant, D. (2024, May 13). Enhancing Aerospace Power Engagement Among the Quad Countries: A Roadmap. Orfonline.org; OBSERVER RESEARCH FOUNDATION (ORF). https://www.orfonline.org/research/enhancing-aerospace-power-engagement-among-the-quadcountries-a-roadmap

Pereira, A., Biddington, B., Rajagopalan, R., & Suzuki, K. (2021). The Quad: Implications for Space. 2021 IEEE Aerospace Conference (50100). https://doi.org/10.1109/aero50100.2021.9438177

Reinecke, A., & Dutcher, M. F. (2023, May 23). The Possibilities for Quad Cooperation in Space. Thediplomat.com; The Diplomat. https://thediplomat.com/2023/05/the-possibilities-for-quadcooperation-in-space/

Two Decades of the Quad: Diplomacy and Cooperation in the Indo-Pacific. (n.d.). Orfonline.org. https://www.orfonline.org/research/two-decades-of-the-quad-diplomacy-and-cooperation-in-the-indopacific